A DNA database to rival the West
2020.06.25 18:48 Makoto Watanabe
4 min read
Roughly 1.2 million profiles are registered in the National Police Agency’s suspect DNA database. That’s one in every 100 citizens.
DNA data has been called the ultimate form of personal information. Police use it to identify culprits by cross-checking DNA found at crime scenes with their database. But are there really 1.2 million suspected criminals in Japan?
In 2009, 74,000 profiles were registered in the database. Now it contains 16 times that number. What happened over the last decade?
After a bit of digging, we noticed a major turning point: a government study group formed in 2010.
In exchange for recording interrogations
The “Study Group for Enhancing Investigation Methods and Interrogation” met regularly from 2010 to 2012.
Led by the chairperson of the National Public Safety Commission, the study group included lawyers, sociologists, journalists, and former police and public prosecutors.
Its objective was as follows.
“Police investigations focused on extracting confessions may become weaker if we implement ‘transparent interrogations’ in order to avoid false charges. In exchange, police should be given robust investigation methods.”
Transparent interrogations (taking audiovisual recordings) were gaining traction in politics around the time the study group was active. False charges propped up by forced confessions — including cases in the cities of Shibushi and Himi — sparked nationwide discussion on improper interrogation techniques (*1).
The study group first convened at the NPA building in Kasumigaseki, Tokyo, on February 5, 2010.
Hiroshi Nakai, then chairman of the National Public Safety Commission, made opening remarks (*2). The commission supervises Japan’s police. Its chairperson holds the rank of minister of state and is appointed by the prime minister, who was from the Democratic Party of Japan during Nakai’s tenure.
“In order to implement the transparent interrogations mentioned in the Democratic Party’s manifesto, we must give our officers new investigation methods similar to those used in foreign countries that record interrogations,” Nakai said in his speech.
“When compared to other countries’ investigation methods, Japan places much more emphasis on interrogation. In many instances, our officers cannot even make arrests — let alone close the case — without a confession,” he continued.
“Japan is lagging behind other countries when it comes to investigation methods other than interrogation. I worry that the number of arrests will fall if we start recording entire interrogations without implementing other methods.”
The police turned to DNA
The police were concerned that it would become more difficult to obtain confessions if everything taking place in the interrogation room were recorded. So the study group considered what investigation methods would help officers solve cases.
Hisashi Kosakai, an attorney and vice-chairperson of the Japan Federation of Bar Associations’ Group for the Institutionalization of Electronic Recordings of Interrogations, was a member of the study group. We spoke with Kosakai at his law office in Osaka (*3).
“The police were most interested in building up their DNA database,” Kosakai said when we asked what investigation methods were put forward to supplement recorded interrogations. “Western nations had databases containing a million DNA profiles, but Japan was working on a much smaller scale at the time. I felt the police were anxious to catch up to and surpass the West.”
“Take a look at this,” Kosakai pointed to the section titled “Enhancing investigation methods” in the study group’s final report.
“Expand the DNA database” was listed first among 12 investigation methods, which also included undercover investigations, plea bargaining, and increased wiretapping.
The section also noted the size of other countries’ databases.
“Five countries maintain databases containing over 300,000 DNA profiles, including the United States (about 8.3 million profiles), the United Kingdom (about 5.6 million profiles), and France (about 1.2 million profiles). These countries hold much more data than Japan (about 190,000 profiles as of the end of 2011).”
What discussions took place regarding the police’s ambitious DNA project?
… To be continued.
(Originally published in Japanese on Nov. 15, 2019. Translation by Annelise Giseburt.)
*1: Japan Federation of Bar Associations, “Transparency of interrogations (recording entire interrogation process): Critique of opposition to transparency (third edition)” March 2008.
*2: Study Group for Enhancing Investigation Methods and Interrogation, “Final report by the Study Group for Enhancing Investigation Methods and Interrogation,” February 2012, page 3.
*3: 31 October 2019On the Hunt for DNA: All articles